The Phillies opened fire on Joe Girard, but their flaws are deeper

For Philadelphia fans who are frustrated with the 76ers, who have followed the NBA failure with only tacit success, the Phillies have a message: Hold my Yuengling.

It should have been mined at Citizens Bank Park, but on Friday the Phillies admitted disaster to their season and fired manager Joe Girard. The 76ers never go far in the NBA postseason, but they still go. It looks like the Phillies are continuing their 11th consecutive season without going through to the playoffs, a stretch that includes just one win.

That was last season and he barely qualifies, 82-80. Team owner John Middleton re-invested in the list with the signing of Nick Castellanos and Kyle Schwarber, thus crossing the league luxury tax threshold for the club’s record $ 228.7 million, which is the 4th highest in the big teams.

Still, the Phillies were 22-29 years old when Dave Dombrowski, the head of baseball operations, fired Girard on Friday morning. Even the Pittsburgh Pirates, who sank into a long-term reconstruction project with a meager $ 55.7 million salary, had a better record.

“I think we are better than what we played,” Dombrowski told a news conference in Philadelphia. “But for me, most importantly, if we’re going to change that and I think we still have the opportunity to do it – I think we needed another vote at the club.”

The Files have appointed Girard’s coach, Rob Thomson, as the team’s interim manager for the rest of the season. Thomson, like Girard, has deep roots in the Yankees’ organization and was part of the staff that defeated the Tiles in the 2009 World Series. He will be Philipp’s sixth coach during their post-season drought, the longest in the national league.

“There are several reasons why we did not win,” Girardi said in his weekly segment on MLB network radio on Friday. “We made a lot of extra outs, which probably cost us four or five games, maybe more. Sometimes our Bulpen fought; We had guys who, in my opinion, have much better items than the potential they used. And some of the guys moved on to slow starts on the attack.

And it happens, right? But I think you can overcome sometimes one, maybe even two. But sometimes, when it’s more, it’s somewhat difficult. “

There is some depreciation. According to Sports Info Solutions, in 50 games, Phyllis finished last in the main rows with defensive runs. As of Thursday, their riders had released 93 rides at 180 inches, compared to 73 rides at 273 inches for beginners. And only one daily player, Bryce Harper, had a base percentage of .325 or better.

The Tiles knew they would not have strong defense, but hoped a rough attack would be able to cover these shortcomings. When they signed the underprivileged suburbs Castellanos (five years, $ 100 million) and Schwarber (four years, $ 79 million), they hoped to use their destination to leave one or the other pitch for most of the games.

But Harper’s rupture of the right elbow ligament forced him to be in full-time DH and Castellanos and Schwarber did not hit hard enough to help. Several returning position players – Alec Bom, Odubel Herrera, Ris Hoskins, JT Realmuto – were mediocre at best.

I take responsibility when the club plays like this; “We all take responsibility,” Dombrovsky said. “I think the players are taking responsibility too. I know they are not happy with what happened. I think we are a better club than that.”

They should still be. When the core of their 2008 championship team collapsed, the Phillies planned to follow a modern plan to create a winner: they would endure several rough years and build a dynamic farm system, then popularize and fill them with expensive stars.

On the way, they fired General Manager Matt Clentack and his hired manager, Gabe Kapler, replaced Dombrowski and Girard, both of whom are well-known inheritors of the Championship. They reassured the mercenaries; With earlier victories, the thought went away, knowing how to do it again.

But Phillies’s shortcomings were deep. They peaked in the top 10 in five drafts in a row, from 2014 to 2018, and found only one player, starter Aaron Nola, who made a big impact. Dombrowski, who was hired in December 2020, revised the team player development headquarters last September.

Harper and beginner Zack Wheeler were reasonable investments, and Realmuto – acquired by trading in Miami, then signed a long-term contract – created two All-Star teams for the Phillies. But without a pipeline of cheap, young players who will get better over time, the Phillies will be forced to continue importing expensive veterans.

This is often a questionable strategy, as many players who have enough time to get a high salary often already reach the peak. Older teams can win, as Girardi’s Yankees did in 2009. But this list was full of players who were treated with dignity in the Hall of Fame; This list of Phillies is much weaker.

Girard could only do so much. Miss Yankee teams had a total of 200 wins more than losses – 910-710. But Girardi’s three Phillies teams went 132-141, a stressful and unfulfilled presence in a demanding sports city. As Dombrowski said when Girard was in the office on Friday, late in the morning, Middleton and others felt a change in his mood.

“In the end, I would say he was much more relaxed,” Dombrowski said. “The pressure was on his back.”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.