Stealing tokens has long been part of a baseball strategy. When a swimmer hits, his teammates carefully observe the catcher’s fingers or body language to figure out what pitch to throw. This is all fair play as long as teams do not use any electronic devices, such as cameras or computers, to facilitate the process.
In previous seasons – the newly published Yankee General Manager, according to a letter sent to Yankee General Manager Brian Cashman in 2017 by the newly published Baseball Major League Baseball – Yankees used electronic devices to decrypt and share the marks of opposing teams. The letter came after the Yankees accused the Boston Red Sox of using a similar process.
“The use of a Dugout phone by the Yankees to convey information about the opposing club’s marks in the 2015 season and part of the 2016 season constitutes a material violation of the rules of reconsideration,” Manfred Keshman wrote.
“In the video review room, instantly transmitting information to Dugut using a telephone in violation of the rules of the piston, the Yankees were able to provide real-time information to their players about the sequence of signs of the opposing club – the same goal. The Red Sox scheme, which was the subject of a Yankee complaint. “
The reason why the Yankees were punished in a less harsh way (a $ 100,000 fine allocated to charity) than the Houston Astros and Boston Red Sox, the World Series winning teams that were fined with suspensions, fines, loss of draft pick and community. Mocking? These teams continued to steal the marks after the MLB began raiding it and imposing clear terms of punishment.
The content of this MLB letter to the Yankees – which went public on Tuesday and was first reported by the SNY before the expected sealing in court – was not new or surprising. The paranoia about opponents stealing marks between pitchers and catchers has existed throughout the history of baseball, but the influx of technology into the game has sparked new fears.
New ways to avoid the rules emerged in 2014 when MLB expanded the use of instant repeat review, creating rooms with live video channels near each team’s dugout to help coaches decide whether to oppose the game. Players were also allowed to visit these rooms during games to watch a video of their hitting or hitting. But any use of technology to decrypt or transmit opponent’s markings during the game was still prohibited.
While there was concern among many teams that their opponents were going too far, the first big public sign that the technology was being misused came in 2017, when The New York Times reported that the Yankees had filed a complaint. In MLB and charged in the Red Sox. Transfer tokens from video game staff to Dugut via Apple Watch. Following an investigation by the Red Sox that resulted in a fine, the MLB acknowledged that it had become increasingly difficult to monitor the misuse of electronics.
“At the time, stealing marks was used as a competitive weapon by many teams across the major baseball league and only became illegal after the commissioner set a specific rule on September 15, 2017,” the Yankees said in a statement on Tuesday. He later added that there had been “no violations or violations” since then.
2022 MLB Season
The season, which was dubious, is suddenly approaching at full speed.
On that day, Manfred sent a memorandum to all 30 teams warning them of stealing illegal tokens, stating that the club’s management and not the players were responsible for such deception. In March 2018, MLB sent the teams another memorandum that made it clear that repeat rooms and video channels were not allowed for stealing tokens during games.
(The MLB has since taken further steps to try to stop such behavior.)
However, here the history of the Yankees goes back to the history of Astros and Red Sox.
According to an MLB investigation published in January 2020, the Astros found that they used the scheme for the 2017 playoffs and at least part of the 2018 season, which included the use of cameras and monitors to decipher the signs of opposing teams and remove Houston batteries. Often by hitting a trash can outside Dugut.
Manfred punished Astros with a one-year suspension for general manager Jeff Luno and manager Eage Hinch, who were subsequently fired by team owner Jim Crane and fined the team $ 5 million and put in a first- and second-round draft. Choose between 2020 and 2021.
According to a separate MLB investigation published in April 2020, the Red Sox were found to be using a scheme that was more restrictive than that of the Astros, but still included decrypting opponent marks while watching live video during games and transmitting it. Information for players.
Manfred punished Red Sox with a one-year suspension from manager Alex Cora, who was also part of the 2017 Astros scheme, and JT Watkins, a Boston video replay operator. The team also lost the second round selection in 2020.
Manfred’s once-personal letter to the Yankees has now come out in a court case over the dismissal of U.S. District Judge Jed S. Rakoff in April 2020, among fantastic sports contestants who claimed they were harmed by stealing a mark in the MLB. Fans who have sued MLB over the Astros and Red Sox have said that Manfred’s 2017 letter to Kashman, which appeared at the time of the discovery, contradicted the league’s public statements at the time.
The Yankees tried to seal the letter, arguing that they were not a party to the case and that it was damaging their reputation. Several judges disagreed, arguing that most of the letter had already been voiced by MLB in its 2017 statement. The U.S. Second Circuit Court of Appeals last week rejected the Yankees’ request for a retrial of the team’s case so that the letter could be sealed.
Manfred’s three-page letter explained to Kashman how the MLB found that Red Sox had broken the league rules. Manfred wrote that during the Red Sox investigation, the league (the person or group whose identity was specified) was told that the Yankees were “using a Red Sox-like scheme” to decipher the marks of opposing teams and pass them on. Dough when the runners were at the second base.
Manfred also wrote that an edited person or group who noticed the Red Sox using the Apple Watch told the league that during the 2015 season and part of 2016, they provided information about opponents’ marks to players and coaches at Yankee Stadium. Repeated room and they, in turn, were taken to Dugut. At certain stadiums along the way, he writes, information was transmitted over Duguti by telephone.
Manfred recently wrote that his office could not find a formal complaint from Red Sox accusing the Yankees of pointing their YES network cameras at Boston Dugout when coaches and players gave signs. He also noted the minor unauthorized use of the iPad by a Yankees coach during the game.
In their statements on Tuesday, MLB and the Yankees noted that much of the content of the letter had been known for some time.
“The Yankees did not violate MLB rules at the time, which regulated the theft of marks,” MLB said. “At the time, the use of a repeat room to decrypt signs was not strictly prohibited under MLB rules unless the information was provided electronically to Dugut. As rules for the use of repetition developed, many clubs moved their video equipment closer to the pitch, allowing staff to quickly transmit signals to the pitch.
The MLB said it clarified its rules on electronic equipment in the Manfred Memorandum on September 15, 2017, and drew a “clear line” on March 27, 2018 that no club or video room equipment could be used to decrypt the signs.
“The Yankees fought vigorously to produce this letter, not only for the legal principle involved, but also to avoid misrepresenting the events that took place before and after the commissioner’s theft rules were established,” the Yankees said. . “What is clear is that the fine stated in the letter to the Major League Baseball was imposed before the new MLB regulations and standards were issued.”